Storytelling in the Courtroom: The 'Arc' of Telling a Riveting Story
- Michael J. DeBlis III, Esq.

- Aug 8
- 2 min read
Updated: Aug 12
In this ebook, I will cover the beats that all great stories go through. From there, I’ll discuss the importance of finding the tempo of the narrative pace, the rule of three’s and how to apply it, and how to build suspense. In doing so, we’ll visit the works of some famous authors like Edgar Allan Poe and Stephen King to see what literary devices they employ. This will enhance your ability to tell your client’s story to the jury in a way that will leave an unforgettable impression.
We'll explore how courtroom storytelling mirrors the timeless structure of classic narratives. Whether you're delivering an opening statement, examining a witness, or making a final plea to the jury, understanding how to construct and convey a compelling story is crucial.
We'll explore the five essential narrative beats all great stories contain—setup, inciting incident, rising action, climax, and resolution—and how these can be mapped onto your case to make your argument more persuasive. We'll dive into the tempo of narrative pacing: how to slow down at key emotional moments, speed up when urgency is required, and keep jurors engaged through rhythm and tone.
Through literary analysis of masters like Edgar Allan Poe, Stephen King, and others, we'll explore how tension is built, how characters (even your client or key witnesses) are developed, and how themes are layered subtly but powerfully. We’ll also explore the Rule of Three, a storytelling principle rooted in cognitive science, which helps make complex legal arguments more digestible and memorable.
Learning Objectives:
Shape facts into narratives that resonate with jurors emotionally and logically
Use suspense and pacing to guide jury attention and maintain engagement
Apply literary devices such as foreshadowing, irony, and metaphor to reinforce your theory of the case
Structure opening and closing arguments to mirror compelling story arcs
Humanize clients and witnesses in ways that foster empathy and connection
This isn’t just about theatrics—it’s about delivering truth with impact.
Areas covered:
Story structure and narrative beats in litigation
Pacing and rhythm in trial storytelling
Application of literary devices in legal arguments
Building suspense and emotional resonance
Using archetypes and character development in client representation
Rhetorical repetition, the Rule of Three, and persuasive phrasing
Classic courtroom storytelling dos and don’ts
In the courtroom, the most compelling argument isn’t always the one with the most evidence—it’s often the one with the best story. Jurors are human beings, not machines, and they respond to emotional logic, moral tension, and well-crafted narratives.
This ebook will equip you with the narrative tools used by the world’s most successful storytellers and show you how to apply them strategically to your next trial. You’ll learn how to connect the jury to your client’s experience on a human level—because when the story sticks, so does the verdict.





Comments